Johan Fourie's blog

I'd rather be a comma than a fullstop

How a love affair changed South African history

with 10 comments

Those endowed with the gift of storytelling, I realised again yesterday, have the power, much like a magician, to cast a spell on their audience. Abraham Lincoln conveyed many of his most important messages through stories; Walt Whitman, American poet and essayist, thought Lincoln’s stories were “a weapon which he employ’d with great skill.” Madiba also used storytelling to powerful effect. And yesterday those lucky few that happened to pass the tea room were enthralled by the spells cast by prof Sampie Terreblanche who, at 80, has a lifetime of stories to share.

Inevitably, the topic started with William and Kate’s newborn baby king. (I personally hoped for a Simba-moment, showing the baby to the world from Buckingham Palace’s balcony, but they decided for a more intimate event.) But the conversation diverged, and prof Terreblanche told of the almost incredulous events that lead to the National Party victory in 1948. I have not checked all the facts (I’m not sure they can be checked), but the story is simply too fabulous to be fabricated. Here goes:

The Greek Princess that inadvertently caused apartheid?

The Greek Princess that inadvertently caused apartheid? Frederica Louisa Thyra Victoria Margareta Sophie Olga Cécilie Isabelle Christa of Hanover (just call me Frederica), Queen consort of the Hellenes. Source:

Prince Paul, the Crown Prince of Greece, and Frederica of Hanover, his wife whom he married in January 1938, had to flee Greece during the Second World War. They first settled on the island of Crete, but when German forces invaded the island too, they moved to London and from there to South Africa. Here they met Jan Smuts, world-renowned statesman and leader of the ruling United Party. Smuts and Frederica became good friends – prof Sampie claims that this relationship was more than platonic – to the extent that Smuts was named the godfather of Princess Irene, born on 11 May 1942 in Cape Town. (Princess Irene, now Princess of Greece and Denmark, still lives in Madrid.) When the War ended, the Greek Royals returned to Greece, but Smuts kept in contact and hoped to visit them soon.

1948 was election year. The elections were scheduled for October, but Jan Smuts was confident of a United Party victory and had plans to travel abroad during the second half of the year. He was nominated to become Chancellor of Cambridge and was required to attend the graduation ceremony during July (which is, incidentally, also the first year women were accepted to Cambridge). His plan was to attend the ceremony, then travel to Israel to visit the new Jewish state and then to Greece to visit Princess Frederica. He thus requested his cabinet to shift the election to the first part of the year –  26 May – so that all would be done in time for him to leave for Cambridge. The shift left his party with little time to discuss election policy, canvass votes and, more importantly, to shift the electoral boundaries (as happens frequently in democracies) in favour of the ruling party. The Reunited National Party (Herenigde Nasionale Party) had a clear message: apartheid between black and white. The United Party’s policy on the ‘Native-problem’ was, at best, muddled.

The rushed election meant that the Reunited National Party won by 6 seats, even though they only gained 37.7% of the total votes compared to the 49% of the United Party. Had the election been in October, there would have been ample time to plan a better election strategy and redraw the electoral boundaries. Quite possibly there would have been no National Party victory.

Chaos theory’s butterfly effect suggests that a small change in the initial condition can have massive repercussions later. If Jan Smuts had not wanted to visit Princess Frederica in Greece, what would a history of South Africa look like today?


Written by Johan Fourie

July 24, 2013 at 07:50

10 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. Dear Panos I replied in a small detail about princess Irene of Greece, there is another explaination even better than mine to explain why princess Irene has the title of her Royal Highness Princess of Greece and Denmark Yes!!!!!!!!!

    Anastasia Veliades

    March 24, 2016 at 15:38

  2. Bitter interessant Johan! Ek geniet jou blog baie!

    Diana Nel-Hugo

    May 20, 2015 at 17:34

  3. Die Suid-Afrikaanse ambassade woning in Athene is skuins oorkant prinses Frederika se destydse huis (dié staan nou toegeplank). Stories wil dit hê dat die Suid-Afrikaanse huis ‘n geskenk van die prinses aan Jan Smuts was, maar dat hy dit toe aan die Unie Van Suid-Afrika oorgedra het. Kan iemand dié storie bevestig?

    Manie Groenewald

    April 8, 2014 at 13:56

  4. Who is the Prof Sampie refered to above and where does he suggest that the relationship was more than just platonic.


    September 12, 2013 at 13:15

  5. You write (Princess Irene, now Princess of Greece and Denmark, still lives in Madrid.)
    There IS NOT such a thing as prince, princess, or…King of Greece. Greece is democratic country. It will be appreciated if you make the correction to ex….thank you.


    July 24, 2013 at 08:43

    • Dear Panos48 –

      I’ve used Wikipedia as my source on Princess Irene:

      Johan Fourie

      July 24, 2013 at 08:51

    • Her Royal Highness Princess Irene of Greece and Denmark is her name. Although her family is not reigning in Greece her title is still valid as per the Vienna Conference which Greece recognizes that all Royals and non -royals will be recognized by there title whether they are in office or not. President Stephanopoulos is addressed still as Mr. President even though he is not in office anymore. Just as His Majesty King Constantine II of Greece is the correct style and form of address even though Greece is a Republic. If he were Reigning his title would be His Majesty, Constantine II, King of The Hellenes.


      April 27, 2014 at 18:55

      • The Kings princes and Princesses still keep their titles also they also belongs to the royal family of Denmark, google to be informed!!!
        Possibly yu all in Greece DON NOT BELIEVE INALL THAT this is the reason the country is gone sta skoupithia nai???????

        Anastasia Veliades

        March 24, 2016 at 15:35

    • Of course the Greek Royal,Family is recognized everywhere except in Greece. They prefer their cleptocrátic political dynasties…


      September 2, 2018 at 12:15

    • Greece is a cleptocratic political dynasty ! The Greek Royal Family is recognized everywhere in the World except in Greece. Denmark, Sweden, Holland or Spain are much better democracies and successful countries than the so called “democracy” of Greece. Greece was a much better managed and respected country under the Crowned Democracy that lasted between 1946 and 1967.


      September 2, 2018 at 12:18

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: